The Real Reason Susan Rice Didn't Deserve to Be Secretary of State6 comments, 0 called-out Comment Now Follow Comments Following Comments Unfollow Comments Comment Now Follow Comments Following Comments Unfollow Comments This article is by Gregory J. Wallance, a lawyer and human rights activist who is the author of America's Soul in the Balance: The Holocaust, FDR's State Department, and the Moral Disgrace of an American Aristocracy. Susan Rice's bid to become secretary of state was derailed because of the Republican uproar over her Sunday morning talk show statements about who was behind the September 11 attack on the U.S. mission in Libya. But although that may have been the causative event, it should not have forced her to withdraw her bid. After all, all she had done was recite the intelligence community consensus. Lost in the political commotion was a recent one-day news story about Ambassador Rice's handling of a pressing human rights issue in Africa. In the fall, Ambassador Rice delayed publication of a United Nations report denouncing Rwanda's support for a rebel group, known as M23, that has committed mass atrocities in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. She also intervened to water down a Security Council resolution that strongly condemned M23 for widespread rape, summary executions, and use of child soldiers in the Congo, where 3 million have died in a decade of violence. The official U.S. government explanation is that more confrontational diplomacy would have jeopardized delicate negotiations with Rwanda, Uganda, and the Congo. Unfortunately, her handling of M23 echoes a shameful event in American diplomatic history. In 1942, when career diplomats of the wartime State Department received a report from the U.S. legation in Switzerland of the Nazi plan to exterminate the Jewish population of Europe, the patrician diplomats suppressed the report because of, as one explained, "the impossibility of our being of any assistance." Then, after the information did get out, they watered down a proposed U.N. war crimes declaration to delete the crucial phrase that the extermination reports "leave no room for doubt." In 1943, as pressure mounted for rescue of Jews trapped in the Nazi extermination machinery, the diplomats instructed the U.S. legation to stop sending more reports of the exterminations, even though they knew that 6,000 Jews were being killed daily at a single location in Poland. Among their reasons: Rescue would have interfered with the war effort, and even if it succeeded, there was no place to put any large number of rescued Jews. The stain on American honor would have lasted for eternity but for the fact that young lawyers in the Treasury Department discovered what the State Department had done. These lawyers, all Christians and idealists, did not intellectualize or rationalize the State Department's conduct. They instantly internalized it. They understood deep down, because they possessed a moral core that had never developed in the diplomats of the State Department, how wrong this was, and they set out to stop it. Ultimately, they succeeded, in part by writing reports to their boss, the Jewish secretary of the treasury, Henry Morgenthau, Jr., which he used to convince President Roosevelt that a scandal was about to explode under him. The Jewish rescue portfolio was yanked from the State Department and vested in a newly created agency, the War Refugee Board, which is credited with saving 200,000 Jews (the board found places to put them, and their rescue did not interfere with military operations). Which brings me back to Susan Rice. Of course any analogy between Ambassador Rice and those heartless wartime U.S. diplomats or between the Congo and Nazi Germany would be unjustified. But a contemporary senior American diplomat surely knew of the moral disgrace of the wartime U.S. diplomats during the Holocaust and, at minimum, should have been sensitive to not treading anywhere near their immoral footsteps. Even if Ambassador Rice missed the various works on the subject, including A Problem From Hell: America and the Age of Genocide, by Samantha Power, now a special assistant to President Obama and senior director for multilateral affairs and human rights at the National Security Council (come to think of it, where was she in all this?), it's safe to say that Rice ignored the consequences of recent callous American diplomacy with which she is undoubtedly familiar. In 1994 President Clinton failed to take effective measures to stop the genocidal massacres in Rwanda, and he now says, "I don't think we could have ended the violence, but I think we could have cut it down. And I regret it," The only regret I have about the withdrawal of Ambassador Rice's bid is that she may escape questioning about her handling of M23, which likely would have come up at some point in a confirmation hearing. Would she have conceded that her policy was insensitive to the moral implications of U.S. diplomats once again blocking reports of massacres and diluting U.N. condemnations of those massacres? Or would she have insisted that fine-tuned diplomatic requirements had trumped the moral issues? These questions raise issues vital to the American response to humanitarian crises, and now they will not be asked. That is the only loss to America from Susan Rice's failed bid to become secretary of state. |
Saturday, 15 December 2012
The Real Reason Susan Rice Didn't Deserve to Be Secretary of State
-“The root cause of the Rwandan tragedy of 1994 is the long and past historical ethnic dominance of one minority ethnic group to the other majority ethnic group. Ignoring this reality is giving a black cheque for the Rwandan people’s future and deepening resentment, hostility and hatred between the two groups.”
-« Ce dont j’ai le plus peur, c’est des gens qui croient que, du jour au lendemain, on peut prendre une société, lui tordre le cou et en faire une autre ».
-“The hate of men will pass, and dictators die, and the power they took from the people will return to the people. And so long as men die, liberty will never perish.”
-“I have loved justice and hated iniquity: therefore I die in exile.”
-“The price good men pay for indifference to public affairs is to be ruled by evil men.”
READ MORE RECENT NEWS AND OPINIONS
-
▼
2012
(689)
-
▼
December
(163)
- HURIRO NYARWANDA: IJAMBO RISOZA UMWAKA
- Rwanda: Une lettre à mon frère Déo...
- FDU-INKINGI: UMWAKA MUSHYA MUHIRE WA 2013, UMWAKA...
- USA: Experts Forecast the Cost of Failure to Compr...
- USA: Experts Forecast the Cost of Failure to Compr...
- Rwanda: les métamorphoses d'un tyran
- Region sucked into conflict as eastern Congo becom...
- Region sucked into conflict as eastern Congo becom...
- Rwanda schemed M23 war - UN expert
- Rwanda schemed M23 war - UN expert
- Mali, la guerre aux mille inconnues | Slate Afrique
- Final report of the Group of Experts on the DRC su...
- Rwanda: FPR ishobora kuba irimo kwicukurira imva m...
- Rwanda: Victoire Ingabire’s Speech and Quotes
- Rwanda: Victoire Ingabire’s Speech and Quotes
- Rwanda’s Rampaging Rebel Force - NYTimes.com
- Rwanda’s Rampaging Rebel Force - NYTimes.com
- The US and the Genocide in Rwanda 1994
- The US and the Genocide in Rwanda 1994
- US chose to ignore Rwandan genocide
- US chose to ignore Rwandan genocide
- The US was behind the Rwandan Genocide
- The US was behind the Rwandan Genocide
- A Dangerous Impasse: Rwandan Refugees in Uganda
- STATE COLLAPSE AND REGIONAL CONTAGION IN SUB-SAHAR...
- RWANDAN ECONOMY AND FOREIGN AID
- Foreign Policy: Kagame makes the Naughty list...
- Foreign Policy: Kagame makes the Naughty list...
- Does the U.S. Support Destabilization in the DR Co...
- Does the U.S. Support Destabilization in the DR Co...
- Acquittés sans terre d'asile : le cas Kabiligi
- Victoire Ingabire spends her third Christmas behin...
- Victoire Ingabire spends her third Christmas behin...
- Rwanda: Inkomoko y’Imiriro Imaze Iminsi Muri Kigali
- RWANDA: IBISABWA BYOSE KUGIRANGO UMUTWE W’INGABO U...
- [VIDEO] Un Jour, Un Destin: Barack Obama, Un Desti...
- Is Rwanda under Kagame becoming the next Zimbabwe?
- Is Rwanda under Kagame becoming the next Zimbabwe?
- Victoire Ingabire: message of strength, dedication...
- Victoire Ingabire: message of strength, dedication...
- Crise à l'Est de la RDC : les véritables motivatio...
- L’ambassade des USA en RDC écrit au Potentiel-A pr...
- [AUDIO] Victoire Ingabire's Third Christmas in Prison
- [AUDIO] Victoire Ingabire's Third Christmas in Prison
- Donors must hold Rwandan government to account for...
- Instability in DRC 'benefits Rwanda and Uganda'
- Fw: *DHR* U.S. under pressure over Rwanda involvem...
- Susan Rice’s defense of Kagame in Congo puts Obama...
- Extrait Chronique d'un génocide (La partie occult...
- Imvo n'Imvano: Isabukuru ya FPR
- Extrait Chronique d'un génocide (La partie occult...
- Ari Perezida Kagame n’abamunenga, ni nde uvuga ibi...
- Kagame akwiriye guhitamo kuba perezida cyangwa ake...
- Vietnam, Afghanistan, Somalia … Congo? The DRC?
- RDC: Chirac et Trierweiler appellent l'ONU à "remp...
- UN Accuse Bishop John Rucyahana of Supporting Murd...
- Rwanda : Kagame Paul siwe wenyine uzaba ubaye umup...
- Rwanda: Tuve Mu Magambo Tujye Mu Bikorwa
- New Pentagon effort will send Army teams to Africa...
- At last Hissène Habré to be tried by the Senegales...
- Ubushinwa bwemereye abanyarwanda Inguzanyo
- Prevent the the cessation of refugee status for Rw...
- Kagame Threatens to Return to the Bush
- Le secret de la longévité de Kagame au pouvoir dév...
- Stop Donating to West – President
- Rubavu: Amavunja yibasiye abaturage
- Susan Rice’s defense of Kagame in Congo puts Obama...
- U.S. under pressure over Rwanda involvement in Con...
- Prevent the the cessation of refugee status for Rw...
- Ben Affleck urged Washington to use its “unique” i...
- Obama urges Rwandan president to stop support for ...
- Rwanda-USA : sous pression, Obama avertit Kagame
- Book: Transitional Justice in Rwanda-Accountabilit...
- Book: Britain's Hidden Role in the Rwandan Genocide
- Worries grow in east Congo with fighter buildup
- 2012 Person of the Year: Barack Obama, the President
- Readout of the President’s Call with President Kagame
- Obama tells Rwanda: end DRC rebel support | The Au...
- US hits more DRC rebel leaders with sanctions : Ne...
- Obama tells Rwanda to end DRC rebel support - FRAN...
- RNC-IHURIRO AND FDU-INKINGI ENCOURAGED BY PRESIDEN...
- Rwanda: Political prisoner Ingabire files an appea...
- Victoire Ingabire: An unwieldy trophy for RPF’s 25...
- Rwanda : FPR mu myaka 25 ntiyageze ku ntego zayo u...
- Rwanda : Le FPR dans son bilan de 25 ans n’a pas a...
- Rwanda: L’histoire de Victoire Ingabire Umuhoza
- Obama purportedly to nominate Kerry, sparking spec...
- Haiti becomes member of the African Union
- US Congress Tackles Rwandan Government Support to ...
- Introduction of Paul Rusesabagina by Robert Krueger
- Remarks to the Rwandan Community
- Kigali wants federal state in eastern DRC, US Cong...
- A Culture That Condones The Killing Of Children An...
- Obama Picks Kerry For Next Secretary Of State « CB...
- Breaking: Now Kabila Attacks Rwanda
- Rice's Failure in Rwanda Precludes Her From Becomi...
- More than 900,000 displaced in east DR Congo
- Obama Gets a Solution to His Susan Rice Problem
- Text of Susan Rice's letter to Obama
- The Real Reason Susan Rice Didn't Deserve to Be Se...
-
▼
December
(163)
Popular Posts
-
http://montjalinews.com/2016/07/28/amateka-yubusabane-bwabanyarwanda/ http://montjalinews.com/...
-
L'armée secrète de Kagame! D'autres hirondelles arrivent... https://www.facebook.com/share/r/hH16f5ZPiSh42emK/?mibextid=UalRPS ### ...
-
If Axel Muganwa Rudakubana had been a son of a Hutu, what would have been the news headlines in Kagame's mouthpiece tabloids? Sinc...
-
White Malice: How the CIA strangled African independence at birth | The Citizen White Malice: How the CIA strangled African independence a...
-
"L'avion a disparu du radar, le transpondeur a peut-être été désactivé, mais je pense que la plus grande probabilité est que l'...
-
Génocide au Rwanda: non-lieu confirmé en appel dans l'enquête sur l'armée française à Bisesero https://www.boursedirect.fr/en/news/c...
-
La RDC porte plainte contre Apple en France et Belgique pour «exploitation et exportation illégale» de minerais https://www.rfi.fr/fr/%C3%A9...
-
Afrikarabia » Négation du génocide des Tutsi du Rwanda : Onana condamné à Paris La XVIIe chambre du tribunal correctionnel de Paris...
-
Bashar al-Assad given asylum in Moscow, Russian media say Bashar al-Assad and his family have arrived in Moscow and been granted asylum ...
-
Syrian insurgents enter Damascus, President Assad flees Syria | AP News Syrian insurgents enter Damascus, President Assad flees Syria | ...
WebMD Health Channel - Sex & Relationships
Love Lectures
How We Made It In Africa – Insight into business in Africa
David DeAngelo - Dating Questions For Men
Christian Carter - Dating Questions For Women
Women - The Huffington Post
Recent Articles About Effective Communication Skills and Self Development
Useful Links
- Africa Works
- Africa Development / Afrique et Developpement
- Africa Desk
- Africa Portal
- International Politics From the Margins
- Democracy in Africa
- Africa in Transition
- African Arguments
- Observatoire de l’Afrique
- International African Institute
- African Studies on H-net
- Royal African Society
- African Studies Association UK (ASAUK)
- African Studies Association (ASA)
- How we made it in Africa
- All Africa
- The Africa Report
- Think Africa Press
- Africa Desk
- African Studies Internet Resource at Columbia University
- African Studies Resource at Columbia University Libraries
- The Nordic Africa Institute
- The African Studies Centre at Leiden University
- African Studies Center at University of Pennsylvania
- Institute of African Studies at Carleton University
- Yale Council on African Studies
- Institute of African Studies at Emory University
- African Studies Program at University of Wisconsin
- Center for African Studies at the University of Florida
- African Studies at Johns Hopkins University
- African and African Diaspora Studies at Boston College
- African Studies Center at Boston University
- African Studies Program at Ohio University
- African Studies Centre at Michigan State University
- Harvard’s Committee on African Studies
- Institute for African Studies at Columbia University
- African Studies Centre at University of Bradford
- Africa Regional Interest Group at Durham University
- Centre of African Studies at SOAS
- Centre of African Studies at University of Edinburgh (UK) :
- Centre for the Study of African Economics at University of Oxford
- United Nations. ReliefWeb
- Institut de recherche pour le developpement
- Global Issues That Affect Everyone
- Africa Files
- Centre for the Study of Human Rights
- Institute for Holocaust and Genocide Studies
- Harvard University Committee on Human Rights Studies
- Institute for the Study of Human Rights
- Montreal Institute For Genocide and Human Rights Studies
- Cohen Center for Holocaust & Genocide Studies
- Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies
- The Center for Human Rights and Genocide Studies
- Strassler Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies
- International Institute for Genocide and Human Rights Studies
- The Stanley Burton Centre for Holocaust and Genocide Studies
- The Genocide Studies Program
- Institute for Anthropological Research in Africa
- The Association of African Universities (AAU)
- The British Institute in Eastern Africa
- The Africa Research in Sustainable Intensification for the Next Generation (Africa RISING)
- Forum for Agricultural Research in Africa
- About Africa Research Online
- Africa Research Institute