Pages

Wednesday, 10 July 2013

Rwanda: Africa's Problem Child


By Felix Njini and Mabasa Sasa Published: 20130708
Africa's Problem Child


Windhoek - Rwanda's army continues to support the DRC rebel group called M23, a group of United Nations experts has said.



In an interim report recently presented to the UN Security Council, the Group of Experts say while Rwanda has scaled down support, Kigali's assistance to the rebels means M23 remains a major security threat in the region.

This is not the first time a UN Group of Experts has revealed the extent of Rwanda's complicity in destabilisation of the SADC member state.

However, the United States and France have repeatedly stonewalled attempts to initiate real Security Council action against Rwanda while paying lip service to calls for peace in DRC.

The interim report was leaked to news agencies this past week and confirms what The Southern Times has previously reported: that instability in the DRC is being fanned primarily by Rwanda.

The interim report clears Uganda – suspected to have been supporting M23 – of involvement but fingers Rwanda.

"Since the outset of its current mandate, the Group has to date found no indication of support to the rebels from within Uganda, and has gathered evidence of continuous - but limited - support to M23 from within Rwanda.

"The Group sent a letter to the government of Rwanda on 14 June 2013 asking for clarification about this support and looks forward to a reply," the UN Group of Experts said.

"The Group received information that M23 commanders have regularly met with Rwanda Defence Forces officers. Three former M23 officers, a former M23 cadre, and several local authorities told the Group that from March to May 2013, they had witnessed M23 Colonels Kaina and Yusuf Mboneza with Rwanda Defence Forces officers," the report went on.

The experts say M23's chain of command is headed by Rwanda's Defence Minister, General James Kabarebe.

The DRC government has told The Southern Times previously that Gen Kabarebe's activities are sanctioned by his President, Paul Kagame.

The UN also says M23 receives "direct military orders from the Rwanda Defence Forces Chief of Defence Staff General Charles Kayonda, who in turn acts on instructions from Minister of Defence James Kabarebe".

The revelations are increasingly embarrassing to Rwanda's Western allies, and this past week US President Barack Obama was forced to issue a mild censure – though he stopped short of directly naming or condemning Kigali.

"The countries surrounding the Congo, they have to make a commitment to stop funding armed groups that are encroaching on territorial integrity and sovereignty of Congo.

"They have signed on a piece of paper, now the question is whether they follow through. Countries surrounding Congo should recognise that if the Congo stabilises, that will improve the prospects of their goals and their prosperity," President Obama said.

The UN report adds that recruitment of child soldiers continues and that M23 is generating income of around US$180 000 a month from "taxes". The rebel group charges amounts ranging from US$200 to US$1 000 – depending on the cargo ‑ for any truck that is transiting through territory that it controls on the DRC's eastern border regions.

The eastern DRC is rich in some of the world's most sought-after minerals, such as coltan, tin, tantalite, diamonds and gold.

The instability in the region has resulted in looting and smuggling of minerals from the DRC, and now Rwanda and Uganda are recording significant gold sales and yet they have no reserves of the mineral to speak of.

 

Kagame's Interests



The questions arise: why is President Kagame so interested in what happens in the DRC? What is in it for Rwanda? And why do the US and France support Rwanda in its destabilisation of the Congo?

Noble Marara, writing for Inyenyeri News, says President Kagame believed Rwanda would have the greatest access to DRC's mineral resources – whose proven quantities have an estimated value of not less than US$24 trillion – following the overthrow of Mobutu Sese Seko in 1997.

"Kagame made Desire Kabila the new President of the DRC, convincing himself that he would use him to control and grab all he laid his hands on in the Congo.

"At that time Kagame had deployed in the DRC most of his senior trusted officers to control not only the wealthy country, but also President Kabila.

"Kagame's own right-hand man, General James Kabarebe, headed the Congolese army.

"President Desire Kabila got a bit sceptical of Kagame's long-term goals …"

President Desire Kabila – who was assassinated in 2001 and succeeded by his son and current President, Joseph Kabila – expelled Gen Kabarebe from the DRC.

Thereafter, President Kagame – a Major-General by military rank – ordered Gen Kaberebe to fight Kabila to the bitter end, writes Marara.

The war from 1998 to 2003 sucked in eight countries at its peak and resulted in the loss of millions of lives, making it the deadliest conflict since World War II. Its legacy of instability still sews horror in the Congo today.

"This was all caused by Kagame wanting to make himself the richest man on the globe," says Marara.



Kabila's Headaches

 

President Joseph Kabila, some experts say, has given much room to the rebels and Rwanda to cause problems in the DRC by failing to create strong state institutions and foster nation-building and reconciliation.

Unbridled corruption (especially in the minerals extraction sector), ethnic tensions and failure to integrate disparate former fighters into the state have all bred dissent.

In November last year, 103 MPs and Senators supported a declaration that President Kabila had essentially not even tried to build a national army during his tenure, and that his tolerance of Rwandan and Ugandan shenanigans in the eastern regions bordered on "high treason".

Among their demands, M23 rebels want command positions in the national army if they are to put down arms, something that President Kabila has been decidedly against.

It is not just armed groups that are giving President Kabila sleepless nights. The political opposition in Parliament continues to frustrate government programmes as it contests his legitimacy.

Recently, opposition parties rejected President Kabila's offer of "national consultations". They said they were not interested in any talks that did not address, among other things, "the looting and selling off of natural resources and (the issue) of ill-gotten gains".

President Kabila's government has tried to advance talks for several months, saying all stakeholders must come together to "reflect on the ways and means to bring a lasting and global response to the crisis afflicting Congolese institutions and parties".

And President Kabila – who attained rank of Maj-Gen before becoming Head of State ‑ cannot always count on his own senior officials and officers to be on his side.

The suspended commander of Congo's national ground forces, Gen Gabriel Amisi Kumba, was accused by the UN of procuring and selling ammunition and weapons to illegal armed groups, including the notorious militia Raia Mutomboki and their enemies the Nyatura, as well as to poachers.

Gen Amisi, a former rebel leader who was integrated into the national army, was essentially "running his own empire" inside the DRC.

Rwanda: Africa's Problem Child


By Felix Njini and Mabasa Sasa Published: 20130708
Africa's Problem Child


Windhoek - Rwanda's army continues to support the DRC rebel group called M23, a group of United Nations experts has said.



In an interim report recently presented to the UN Security Council, the Group of Experts say while Rwanda has scaled down support, Kigali's assistance to the rebels means M23 remains a major security threat in the region.

This is not the first time a UN Group of Experts has revealed the extent of Rwanda's complicity in destabilisation of the SADC member state.

However, the United States and France have repeatedly stonewalled attempts to initiate real Security Council action against Rwanda while paying lip service to calls for peace in DRC.

The interim report was leaked to news agencies this past week and confirms what The Southern Times has previously reported: that instability in the DRC is being fanned primarily by Rwanda.

The interim report clears Uganda – suspected to have been supporting M23 – of involvement but fingers Rwanda.

"Since the outset of its current mandate, the Group has to date found no indication of support to the rebels from within Uganda, and has gathered evidence of continuous - but limited - support to M23 from within Rwanda.

"The Group sent a letter to the government of Rwanda on 14 June 2013 asking for clarification about this support and looks forward to a reply," the UN Group of Experts said.

"The Group received information that M23 commanders have regularly met with Rwanda Defence Forces officers. Three former M23 officers, a former M23 cadre, and several local authorities told the Group that from March to May 2013, they had witnessed M23 Colonels Kaina and Yusuf Mboneza with Rwanda Defence Forces officers," the report went on.

The experts say M23's chain of command is headed by Rwanda's Defence Minister, General James Kabarebe.

The DRC government has told The Southern Times previously that Gen Kabarebe's activities are sanctioned by his President, Paul Kagame.

The UN also says M23 receives "direct military orders from the Rwanda Defence Forces Chief of Defence Staff General Charles Kayonda, who in turn acts on instructions from Minister of Defence James Kabarebe".

The revelations are increasingly embarrassing to Rwanda's Western allies, and this past week US President Barack Obama was forced to issue a mild censure – though he stopped short of directly naming or condemning Kigali.

"The countries surrounding the Congo, they have to make a commitment to stop funding armed groups that are encroaching on territorial integrity and sovereignty of Congo.

"They have signed on a piece of paper, now the question is whether they follow through. Countries surrounding Congo should recognise that if the Congo stabilises, that will improve the prospects of their goals and their prosperity," President Obama said.

The UN report adds that recruitment of child soldiers continues and that M23 is generating income of around US$180 000 a month from "taxes". The rebel group charges amounts ranging from US$200 to US$1 000 – depending on the cargo ‑ for any truck that is transiting through territory that it controls on the DRC's eastern border regions.

The eastern DRC is rich in some of the world's most sought-after minerals, such as coltan, tin, tantalite, diamonds and gold.

The instability in the region has resulted in looting and smuggling of minerals from the DRC, and now Rwanda and Uganda are recording significant gold sales and yet they have no reserves of the mineral to speak of.

 

Kagame's Interests



The questions arise: why is President Kagame so interested in what happens in the DRC? What is in it for Rwanda? And why do the US and France support Rwanda in its destabilisation of the Congo?

Noble Marara, writing for Inyenyeri News, says President Kagame believed Rwanda would have the greatest access to DRC's mineral resources – whose proven quantities have an estimated value of not less than US$24 trillion – following the overthrow of Mobutu Sese Seko in 1997.

"Kagame made Desire Kabila the new President of the DRC, convincing himself that he would use him to control and grab all he laid his hands on in the Congo.

"At that time Kagame had deployed in the DRC most of his senior trusted officers to control not only the wealthy country, but also President Kabila.

"Kagame's own right-hand man, General James Kabarebe, headed the Congolese army.

"President Desire Kabila got a bit sceptical of Kagame's long-term goals …"

President Desire Kabila – who was assassinated in 2001 and succeeded by his son and current President, Joseph Kabila – expelled Gen Kabarebe from the DRC.

Thereafter, President Kagame – a Major-General by military rank – ordered Gen Kaberebe to fight Kabila to the bitter end, writes Marara.

The war from 1998 to 2003 sucked in eight countries at its peak and resulted in the loss of millions of lives, making it the deadliest conflict since World War II. Its legacy of instability still sews horror in the Congo today.

"This was all caused by Kagame wanting to make himself the richest man on the globe," says Marara.



Kabila's Headaches

 

President Joseph Kabila, some experts say, has given much room to the rebels and Rwanda to cause problems in the DRC by failing to create strong state institutions and foster nation-building and reconciliation.

Unbridled corruption (especially in the minerals extraction sector), ethnic tensions and failure to integrate disparate former fighters into the state have all bred dissent.

In November last year, 103 MPs and Senators supported a declaration that President Kabila had essentially not even tried to build a national army during his tenure, and that his tolerance of Rwandan and Ugandan shenanigans in the eastern regions bordered on "high treason".

Among their demands, M23 rebels want command positions in the national army if they are to put down arms, something that President Kabila has been decidedly against.

It is not just armed groups that are giving President Kabila sleepless nights. The political opposition in Parliament continues to frustrate government programmes as it contests his legitimacy.

Recently, opposition parties rejected President Kabila's offer of "national consultations". They said they were not interested in any talks that did not address, among other things, "the looting and selling off of natural resources and (the issue) of ill-gotten gains".

President Kabila's government has tried to advance talks for several months, saying all stakeholders must come together to "reflect on the ways and means to bring a lasting and global response to the crisis afflicting Congolese institutions and parties".

And President Kabila – who attained rank of Maj-Gen before becoming Head of State ‑ cannot always count on his own senior officials and officers to be on his side.

The suspended commander of Congo's national ground forces, Gen Gabriel Amisi Kumba, was accused by the UN of procuring and selling ammunition and weapons to illegal armed groups, including the notorious militia Raia Mutomboki and their enemies the Nyatura, as well as to poachers.

Gen Amisi, a former rebel leader who was integrated into the national army, was essentially "running his own empire" inside the DRC.

Labour and the Conservatives have both been too soft on Rwanda aid - Telegraph


Labour and the Conservatives have both been too soft on Rwanda aid
Rwanda's President Paul Kagame (left) with Andrew Mitchell in July 2011
Rwanda's President Paul Kagame (left) with Andrew Mitchell in July 2011
Picture: Reuters
Twitter
42
Facebook
33
Share
75

Aid to Rwanda should be conditional on the upholding of human rights and a no-tolerance approach to corruption, write Ivan Lewis and Ian Lucas.

The eastern provinces of the Democratic Republic of Congo have, for many years, posed one of the toughest challenges to international law and order. Following the horrendous Rwandan genocide in 1994 and consequential cross-border impact, perpetual conflict has led to 5.4 million people losing their lives, 2.2 million displaced civilians and a permanent humanatarian crisis. A culture of impunity has meant levels of sexual violence in Eastern DRC are among the worse in the world and such violence is systematically used as a weapon of war. Weak governance and the exploitation of the enormous mineral wealth the region holds have led to the emergence of a multitude of militia groups. Extreme poverty blights the lives and life chances of the vast majority of citizens.

After a three-year period of relative stability and closer security cooperation between DRC and Rwanda, the political and security situation in Eastern DRC has once again worsened during the past year. This was precipitated by an armed rebellion by a breakaway militia from the DRC army, the M23 group which has close links to Rwanda and seized the regional capital of Goma. This happened despite the presence of MONUSCO, the largest UN peacekeeping force anywhere in the world, consisting of 17,000 troops. Unfortunately, when tested on this occasion and others the force has failed to maintain security and protect the civilian population.

Only a coherent strategy combining security, a regional political process and sustainable long-term development has the possibility of achieving change in eastern DRC. In this context it is essential that the international community supports the implementation of the Peace, Security and Cooperation Framework (PCSF) initiative which attempts to bring stability and prosperity to eastern DRC. This was agreed in February 2013 and signed up to by 11 countries. The deployment of an additional African Union brigade with a more assertive mandate to strengthen UN forces together with appointment of Mary Robinson as the UN Secretary General's special envoy also offer a glimmer of hope.

Crucial to any progress in Eastern DRC is the DRC's relationship with Rwanda. The UK and Rwanda enjoy a close relationship built on partnership, trust, and respect. We recognise the horrendous and long-term scars caused by the Rwandan genocide and the significant progress the government of Rwanda led by President Kagame has made to generate substantial economic growth and reduce poverty. Rwandans value their relationship with the UK, both with this Tory-led Government and its Labour predecessor.

This relationship, however, has been tested by the suspension of UK general budget support to Rwanda in November 2012. This decision was rightly made in response to a report by the UN Group of Experts which alleged that ministers in the Rwandan government had been supporting the M23 rebels in eastern DRC.

This involvement was a breach of the partnership principles which underpin the rules by which general aid from UK to Rwanda is dispersed. These principles include a commitment by the Rwandan government to take strong action to tackle corruption, to extend accountability and transparency to their citizens, and to adhere to international obligations to respect human rights and to support peace. The British Government has made it clear that any decision to reinstate general budget support to Rwanda must clearly be informed by these partnership principles. That is why we opposed Andrew Mitchell's premature reinstatement of general budget support and welcomed Justine Greening's reversal of his decision.

Ongoing concerns relating to the registration of opposition political parties and lack of an open political culture in Rwanda has also challenged Rwanda's adherence to the partnership principles. At this crucial time, the UK should take steps to support Rwanda's progress to a more open political culture. It is unclear whether Justine Greening raised these concerns with President Kagame during her recent, low-profile visit to Kigali.

It is essential that any decision to restart direct UK funding to the Rwandan Government must be conditional on the partnership principles being upheld. More specifically, Labour will only support the reinstatement of direct UK funding if it can be demonstrated that for at least a 12-month period no direct or indirect support has been provided by the Government of Rwanda to militias operating in DRC. Recent press reports suggest an updated UN report which has not yet been published will state such support has continued, albeit on a smaller scale. This would be unacceptable. In addition, we want the Government to make it clear publically that should President Kagame seek to change the Rwandan constitution at any stage in order to seek a third term of office in 2017, this would raise serious questions about the future of UK support. We would urge other donors to send the same message.

Despite the inherent risks, Labour continues to support the concept of general budget support as a key element of progressive development policy. Supporting Governments to build effective state institutions is a key element of achieving long-term sustainable change. However, there should be more stringent conditionality than there has been under successive British governments, specifically in relation to human rights and corruption.

It is indisputable that under President Kagame's leadership Rwanda has achieved levels of growth and poverty reduction which compare favourably with anywhere in the world. However, Labour and the Tories have been wrong to give him and other leaders "donor darling" status. Too often it can fuel in those leaders an unhealthy belief that their allies will look the other way, however unacceptable their behaviour.

Equally, the DRC leadership should not suggest all their problems are connected with Rwandan interference in the East of the country. It is time they started taking responsibility for improving the lives of their citizens. It is also time donors including the UK showed leadership and moved from perpetual humanitarian assistance to a development plan which matches the scale of the challenge. The UK occupies a pivotal position and should work with neighbouring countries and the international community to deliver long overdue change. The people of Eastern DRC deserve better.

Ivan Lewis is shadow secretary of state for international development and MP for Bury South; Ian Lucas is shadow minister for Africa and the Middle East and MP for Wrexham.

Twitter
42
Facebook
33
Share
75

-“The root cause of the Rwandan tragedy of 1994 is the long and past historical ethnic dominance of one minority ethnic group to the other majority ethnic group. Ignoring this reality is giving a black cheque for the Rwandan people’s future and deepening resentment, hostility and hatred between the two groups.”

-« Ce dont j’ai le plus peur, c’est des gens qui croient que, du jour au lendemain, on peut prendre une société, lui tordre le cou et en faire une autre ».

-“The hate of men will pass, and dictators die, and the power they took from the people will return to the people. And so long as men die, liberty will never perish.”

-“I have loved justice and hated iniquity: therefore I die in exile.

-“The price good men pay for indifference to public affairs is to be ruled by evil men.”

READ MORE RECENT NEWS AND OPINIONS

Popular Posts

WebMD Health Channel - Sex & Relationships

Love Lectures

How We Made It In Africa – Insight into business in Africa

David DeAngelo - Dating Questions For Men

Christian Carter - Dating Questions For Women

Women - The Huffington Post

Recent Articles About Effective Communication Skills and Self Development